Thursday, December 5, 2013

Polishing & Revising your Essay on Hamlet Films

Polishing & Revising your Essay on Hamlet Films

Pay attention to all these details while Polishing & Revising your Essay on Hamlet Films

Areas to work on:             opening  analyze film more
 MLA header      title    MLA punctuation  introduction          
 thesis sentence      organization            clarity of syntax
 more precise word choices   development of main idea
 clarify & exemplify main idea  narrow main idea [] film details
 topic sentences   body ¶s   closing sentences of  paragraphs   
 conclusion   comma splice  agreement  ‘s  Works Cited 

A or A-
-outstanding, sharp insight into films
-clear and consistent mastery
-a few minor errors
-effectively, insight-fully develops a point of view on the issue
-demonstrates outstanding critical thinking
-use clearly appropriate examples and details from films
-v. well organized &
clearly focused
-demonstrates clear coherence
-smooth progression of ideas
-exhibits skillful use of language
-uses varied, accurate, apt   vocabulary
-demonstrates meaningful variety
   in sentence structure
-free of most errors in grammar,  usage, & mechanics
The Best essays have the following:
Thesis is interesting, arguable, incisive; limited in scope; developed
Structure is: logical, progressive (not just a list), invites complications, counterarguments, with links between points; coherent, well-organized paragraphs •
Evidence is: convincing, well-chosen; readable and understandable, well-analyzed •
Analysis is: fresh; more than summary; shows how evidence supports thesis; Quotes: well-chosen cited correctly
Style is: clear, conversational yet sophisticated; diction level appropriate to audience; smooth, a pleasure to read

Ideas: Be very observant in comparing films and infer insightfully from small details significant differences in interpretation.

Give Evidence that describes what you see on the screen very evocatively and infers insightfully from those visual details.
The Picky stuff:
·          Include an MLA header with last name (space) page number
·          Include a properly formatted and separate MLA Works Cited page listing films and Hamlet
·          Use apostrophes. Avoid fragments.
·          Start every body paragraph with a clear claim in a topic sentence, supply evidence from the play and the films, and then analyze the evidence to show how it supports your claims
·          Use effective paragraphing: paragraph unity, not too many ideas per paragraph, reinforce the main idea in the last sentence

·          Make your thesis specific about what is different in both films.

  Turning in your (awesome) English IV college-level essay:
]
·         LETTER: On the back of the back page, write a ‘Dear Dr. Forman’ letter:
o   Describe in some detail your writing process, from brainstorming to reading the texts to discussing in class to drafting in class to revising at home, to writing on paper to writing on an iPad or laptop to revising to editing to proofreading. Which steps were difficult?
o   What were the biggest challenges you faced? (And how did you try to overcome them?)
o   What went well in this essay that you are proud of?
o   By the time you start college, based on this writing this essay, what new goals do you have for your essay writing? (more vocab/sentence level or more ideas?)
o   What is the best idea you came up with in you essay?
·         CORRECTIONS: Maximum two minor errors per page. It’s not too late to make neat black ink corrections. Pass the essay to the right and ask the person NOT to mark anything, but to proofread carefully for typos or errors and then to ask you if you yourself want to neatly correct them.
·         It’s not too late to add or change a title, to make an ink header, or make simple, neat corrections (but not too many). Look over your essay before you turn it in. 

Thursday, November 14, 2013

Comparing Hamlet Films

Comparing Hamlet Films

This next three and a half weeks we will be studying film. In class, we will be watching six different versions of Act I scene 2 from Hamlet, including the following:
·         Laurence Olivier (1948)                 
·         Derek Jacobi BBC (1980)                               
·          Mel Gibson (1990)                         
·          Kenneth Branagh (1996)
·          Ethan Hawke (2000)
·          David Tennant BBC (2010)
We live near Hollywood, but how many students know how to use a film in the same way we use texts? Students who are used to “finding quotes” for their essays will have to adjust to this new text? How does one ‘quote’ a film? How does one even watch a film critically to write about it? If we stop films, how do we analyze the composition and framing of the still shot? How do we separate the story from the acting? We are so used to talking about characters from movies as if they were people, but how does seeing Branagh, Tennant, and Gibson act the same exact line tease out the performances? What if the scripts were always the same and that we supposed directors and actors were constantly making directorial choices to emphasize different aspects of every line? We might even pay attention to which word in every line is emphasized in different versions? With this level of microscopic scrutiny, we might be able to make claims about different versions.


We are preparing for next year’s college writing this year. What new skills will we be learning from this slightly different assignment?
·         Visual literacy, with the ability to ‘read’ what’s going on visually in a still or short clip
·         Understanding that all staging is interpretation, with the script as a mere blueprint for a building and directors and actors making small choices at every stage that accumulate into larger choices and interpretations
·         Writing out descriptions of visuals to use as evidence in one’s essay
·         Making bold claims based on what you see
·         Taking into account other factors of film: lighting, shot cuts, music, setting, and many other aspects of film
·         Narrowing down what you are focusing on: picking only two films, picking only a few lines, focusing on one character or one relationship, or perhaps picking out from all the other factors only one aspect of the films: transitions, shot angles, lighting, music, etc.
·         As usual, sustaining an argument from a small observation and structuring your essay with support that convinces the reader of your bold, interesting, and original claim
All of this is possible in this one assignment if you really engage with it. There are no right answers. Place yourself in the director’s chair and see what you can discover by comparing films. 

Friday, October 25, 2013

Work on your Hamlet essay

IMPROVING A THESIS BY ADDING SPECIFICS
TOO GENERAL
Shakespeare gives Hamlet and Claudius different language to show their different characters.

BETTER
Shakespeare gives Hamlet and Claudius performative language that disguises their inner feelings; Hamlet acts crazy and manic to cover up his depression and plotting for revenge while Claudius uses long, royal-sounding speeches to cover up his insecurity and guilt.

sample thesis statements
Hamlet's private and public speeches greatly reflect his differing confidence levels; furthermore, when he is alone he doubts himself, and when is is surrounded by his peers he is fearless.

Although Hamlet seems distraught by both his father's death and his mother's untimely marriage, his seemingly crazy behavior is a facade for the true mockery of his peers. In public, he mocks both his mother and Polonius, while in private contemplation, he criticizes himself. 

His father’s death has caused Hamlet to enter an extreme state of craziness that only allows logical thought process when interacting with others; however, when alone he is driven mad.


In Shakespeare’s tragedy, Hamlet, Hamlet utilizes different tones to speak to different people. In private when he speaks to himself, he releases the suffering he is going through after his father's death. He is depressed and also is the epitome of a confused individual. Furthermore, when he is with other people he either mocks them, is serious with them but camouflages his real actions and thoughts with his talks/speech/conversations/language.

Before Monday, blog your very specific working thesis that makes a bold claim about how Shakespeare gives different characters different speech, language, and words.

Reread the assignment. Find quotes that help support your claim.

Before Tuesday, blog you introductory paragraph.

Before Thursday, blog any body paragraph.

Before Monday, Nov. 4, print off a copy of your essay and email a copy to jforman@buckley.org.

Monday, October 14, 2013

What's bothering Hamlet?

Rank what's bothering Hamlet: (and perhaps make it a subject of your next blog)
1. His father's dead
2. His mother married his uncle after two months
3. He has a new stepfather
4. He should have been king
5. What the ghost tells him (at the end of Act I)

 YOU ARE THE DIRECTOR!

Pick one of these short scenes, pair up or form a small group, and prepare the scene to be acted in class. Be sure to explain your acting and performance choices afterwards.

3 people act short scene in Act I: p.727 line 40 to p. 728 line 62:   King, Laertes, Polonius

2 people act short scene in Act I p.736 line 88 to p.737 line 115: Ophelia, Polonius

2 people act short scene in Act I p.741 line 1 to p.742 line 32: Ghost, Hamlet

3 people act short scene in Act I p.744 line 111 to p.745 line 155: Horatio, Marcellus, Hamlet

Thursday, October 10, 2013

Perform Hamlet Act I scene 2

      PREPARE ACTING NOTES AND THEN PERFORM THIS SCENE
      Come up with acting notes in preparation to perform this scene.
·         Be ready to explain your choices afterwards (or before).
·         Perform the scene on video or in front of the class.
·         Explain your acting choices.

 

 KING CLAUDIUS       outline your performance choices for each line and why. Refer to films.
HAMLET
KING CLAUDIUS
àHow is it that the clouds still hang on you?  [Aggressive? Kind? ]
HAMLET
QUEEN GERTRUDE
HAMLET
QUEEN GERTRUDE
HAMLET
KING CLAUDIUS
QUEEN GERTRUDE
àLet not thy mother lose her prayers, Hamlet:
I pray thee, stay with us; go not to Wittenberg.
         [How? Commanding? Pleading? Tender?]
HAMLET
àI shall in all my best obey you, madam.      [How to act this? Submissive? Resentful? Beaten?]
KING CLAUDIUS

·         Come up with acting notes in preparation to perform this scene.
·         Be ready to explain your choices afterwards (or before).
·         Perform the scene on video or in front of the class.
·         Explain your acting choices.













Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Reading Hamlet (with SciFi)

We're going to start reading Hamlet and see if we can make any connections with our first SciFi unit.
Reading schedule:
by Thu. Oct. 17 Finish reading Act I
by Thu. Oct. 24 Finish reading Act II
by Thu. Oct. 31 Finish reading Act. III
by Thu. Nov. 7 Finish reading Act IV
by Thu. Nov. 14 Finish reading Act V


As we're reading, blog four times a week. Blogs are due to be posted before by advisory (10:30) on class days (Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays.)
Blog about a passage that you read or a scene that you liked or a character that confuses you. Blogs should be a paragraph in length, more than just bullet points or just two sentences.

We will be writing blogs, short pieces, and essays about Hamlet along the way.




Analyze Essay about Androids

            In “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?” Philip K. Dick portrays androids and humans as, in some cases, almost interchangeable beings. The author provides examples of both humans acting like androids, and androids acting like humans. In Dick’s novel, what seems to divide humans and androids is empathy; this can be seen by the fact that the test to distinguish human from android is an empathy test called the Voigt-Kampff test. In this futuristic world of humans lacking empathy, and androids displaying empathy, the defining characteristics that used to separate humans and androids are blurred and almost obliterated completely.
            Phil Resch is bounty hunter, but more importantly a human. His job is to hunt down rogue androids and retire them. Similarly to the android Pris Stratton, who, with no feelings of regret “snipped off one of the spider’s legs… restraining the spider with the edge of her hand.” (Dick 206), Resch has the ability to kill without feeling any guilt. Conventionally, a human should have and show feelings, whereas an android should feel nothing. Although Resch passed the empathy test, he still lacks empathy in its entirety. Stratton acts like an android “should”, but not all androids do. Resch eventually, before his empathy test, starts to questions whether or not he is an android. This questioning is precisely one of Dick’s subtle yet convincing blurs in the greyness of human identity.
            Although Luba Luft does not question her identity as an android, she still reflects human emotions. This can best be seen by the genuine gratitude she expresses towards Rick Deckard after he offers to buy her a piece of art that she seemed to like. Luft eventually admits to Deckard: “It’s very nice of you… an android never would have done that.” (Dick 134). Luft is touched by Deckard’s act of kindness, and feels thankful. According to society, an android would never have recognized such an action. Another example of an android being confused with a human is Rachael Rosen. Rosen had false memories implanted in her, and for all her life, though she was a human. Even after discovering she was an android, she still seems to feel emotion towards Deckard. At one point, when the two are in a hotel room, she says that she loves him. One being displaying feelings of love to another being certainly seems to be an emotion attached to a “human.

Questions to answer about the essay, Phillip Dick, and the topic of androids
1.       Underline what you think are strong claims in the essay and be able to summarize them.
2.       Circle examples that are used effectively as support for those claims.
3.       What is the author of this essay claiming about sports media?
4.       Find in the text a quote or paragraph that is relevant to the topic or this essay
                                                               i.      Mark that place in the text and prepare to discuss it with a partner or the whole class.
5.       Discuss the essay and the book.
6.       Write on paper or your blog about the discussion. Focus on one key point that interests you.

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Essay Writing

Dear Doctor letters on first essay; Oct. 2, 2013

By college, students say they want more VOCABULARY and not being REDUNDANT and having a CLEAR THESIS and have a clear POINT and ANALYZE THINGS FURTHER
·         I need to work on expanding my vocabulary to a more intellectual diversity of words as opposed to using same ones many times.
·         By the time I start college I want to expand my vocabulary and be able to use ‘fancy’ words.
·         By college I will have a plethora of more vocabulary.

MOST DIFFICULT
·         I was a little rusty after the summer.
·         Brainstorming
·         Knowing what I wanted to say
·         I get very distracted and it takes me a long time
·         Structuring my ideas in a way captivates the reader
·         Proofreading is the most difficult task
·         Finding synonyms for words because I did not want to be redundant
·         Coming up with a TITLE!
PROCESS             
·         I read through it a couple of times and I began to notice a lot of small possible symbols and even motifs. The more I read each poem the more interesting it became.
·         Reading the two poems constantly and getting the gist of each. Then I analyzed the language or each which led me to my main idea.
·         I prefer writing on paper because I seem to get more connected with my work instead of on an iPad or computer. (except I do with my brain had autocorrect at times).
·         The second run through I physically write on the side what I want to add or change.

NOTE: CREATE A PAGE CALLED "WORKING ON"
Type the chief comments from your essay that you will pay most attention to in your next essay:
àPAGES: Add pages with top tabs
1.       View your blog
2.       Click design (upper right)
3.       Click Pages
4.       Show pages: pull down “Top Tabs”
5.       Click New page (blank page)
6.       Page title: “WORKING ON”
7.       In the body type the following:
a.       ERRORS YOU MADE THAT YOU WANT TO AVOID NEXT TIME
b.      OVERALL ESSAY TIPS THAT YOU WILL WORK ON
c.       FORMATTING ERRORS OR GRAMMAR ERRORS
8.       Click “Publish”
 

Monday, September 30, 2013

Blog about Phillip Dick

Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? Phillip K. Dick


Read the rest of this book by Oct. 7 and blog four times, Mon., Tue, Wed. and Sunday nights. Blog about a paragraph response to what you’ve been reading. Don’t summarize. Instead explore interesting questions that the author raises, as we’ve been doing in class and as you did for your first essay.
Here are some passages to respond to (if you need a place to start):
Explain these quotes and the issues they raise:
p.100 “that other cold, which he had encountered in so many androids.” (empathy)

p.98 “I’m part of the form-destroying process of entropy.” (entropy)
also see p.65 “First Law of Kipple” (compare to second law of thermodynamics)

p.95 “knowing intellectually that they were machines, but emotionally reacting anyhow.” (knowing vs. emotional attraction to androids)

p.94 “Most androids I’ve known have more vitality and desire to live than my wife.” (androids vs. wives)

p.90-91 “one of them will get you” (is Rachael sincere?)

p.85 “Polokov is mimicking a special, an anthead” (deceit vs. sincerity in Asimov)

p.69 Buster Friendly vs. Wilbur Mercer: can you explain both?

P.59 “Does she know?” (Rachael doesn’t know she’s not human. How can machines be given consciousness and false memories? What are the implications

MORE QUESTIONS AND PAGE NUMBERS:
102 Luba Luft outsmarts Rick. How can she? Is this Asimov’s 3rd Law?

122 Garland convinces Rick that Phil Resch is an Android, then admits he is one.

130 Phil Resch clings to the fact that he has a pet squirrel as a sign that he is not an android

132 Luba Luft like most androids gives up. The will to live is just a program, not a life force.

133 Luba is touched by Rick’s gesture to buy her a gift

140-142 Phil passes the test, but doesn’t have a lot of empathy and likes to kill. Rick has empathy for female androids. What does that mean to you?

150 Androids are lonely too!  (Pris Staton)

156 John Isidore thinks androids are strange, but still wants to protect them. They are the only friends he has.

161 flattening of affect = no empathy

161 androids turn each other in, with no empathy

178 Mercer speaks to Rick, but is not a religious figure

187-195 Rachael and Rick in a hotel room

197 Rachael only has two years to live. Rick would marry her.
202 Rachael is victorious over Rick.

206 Pris, who is living with John, mutilates a spider, no empathy. John hates it.
214 John bonds with Mercer and heals the spider.
220 Mercer warns Rick before he is killed.
227 Rick and Iran’s goat is killed
230-233 Depressed, Rick goes to barren Oregon and climbs a hill, gets hit with a rock
236 & 241 Rick finds an extinct toad but Iran discovers it is electric and calls the faux vet
 

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Revise your first essay by Sept. 26

 English IV Essay due to Dr. Forman Sept. 26
Revise your rough draft into a polished final draft
Due Thur Sept. 26 for A & F periods (both hardcopy in class and email Word attachment)
◊2-4 page polished essay, double-spaced with proper formatting (100 points)
◊Revised, edited, proofread, no more than two errors per page
◊Must have a main point (a point of view, a claim) that is not too obvious
◊Compare and/or contrast two basketball poems (A period)
   Or Asimov’s vs. Phillip Dick’s portrayal of robots (F period)
◊Header in upper right hand corner (last name, space, #)
◊Upper left hand corner: name, class, period, date, teacher
◊Title: unique to your essay, should preview your essay topic
◊Opening sentence that hooks the reader
◊Introduction that sets up your argument and context
◊Thesis statement: most specific sentence you can craft that outlines your main argument and analysis. Revise this sentence several times, even after you write your paper.
 ◊Paragraphs: topic sentences that are not examples, but claims, then quotes, evidence, examples carefully analyzed to show how they support your claims. End paragraphs with your main point or a transition.
◊Conclusion: Your best points and their larger implications. If you use ‘I,’ use it in the conclusion.
◊Proofread carefully for errors, especially these: 1) ‘s possessives
2) its vs. it’s
3) comma before quote: ,” not “,
4) don’t underline your own title
5) don’t space differently between paragraphs
6) poems in quotes, novels in italics (“Fast Break” vs. I, Robot)
 7) avoid sentence fragments
8) Works Cited: separate page listing all the works you’ve consulted in alphabetical order
9) avoid comma splices
10) proper imbedded parenthetical citations: “insignia” (Hirsch line 20)
11) don’t risk plagiarism by searching the internet without citing your sources and finally
12) proofread after you print.
Most important of all, in college essays, you must have something to say and know what it is.

Monday, September 16, 2013

How do you organize a compare/contrast essay? So many possibilities

1. Brainstorm ideas for comparing robots in Asimov vs. androids in Phillip Dick
2. Sketch out a structure for your essay: intro, 1st body paragraph, etc.
3. Come up with a working thesis (that you will revise)
4. Post your outline and working thesis to your blog by Wed.
5. Complete a rough draft of your essay by Thursday
6. Keep reading Phillip Dick every night

Remember there are many ways to structure an essay
simplest structure:
intro+thesis
similarities
dfferences
conclu


Remember, a thesis should be as specific a statement of your main claim
Don't list 3 examples like a History essay
Revise, revise, revise your thesis (like your college essay)

A. intro+thesis
similarities in how Asimov/Dick portray robots
differences
conclusion

B. intro+ thesis: human relationships to robots
1. Robbie is loved by Gloria/Dad by hated by neighbors and mom
2. Androids are offered as bribes to emigrate to Mars, master/slave
3. Rick Deckard hunts down and kill rogue robots
4. synthesize all relationships to robots
conclusion

C. intro+ thesis
1. relationships to Robbie v. andy (Asimov v. Dick)
2. IQ of Robbie v. andy
3. Moral structure of Robbie v. andy
conclusions